Consign Sports Cards & Pokemon – Fast Payouts | Columbia Sports Cards
Consign with Columbia
Buy. Protect. Grade. Sell. Collect. Turn your cards and collectibles into cash — we handle everything from grading and listing to shipping and payouts.
How It Works
Submit Your Items
Complete our quick form and ship or drop off your cards. We log every item the day it arrives.
Inspection & Listing
We review condition, prepare images, and create optimized listings on eBay.
Sale & Service
We manage auctions/offers, buyer messages, returns, and all shipping & fulfillment.
Payout
Choose ACH, check, or store credit. You’ll receive a detailed report with every payout.
What We Accept
- Graded & ungraded sports cards
- Pokémon, TCG, & non-sports cards
- Sealed boxes & packs (condition reviewed)
- Certified autographed memorabilia
Not accepted: damaged items, non-certified autographs, or items under $10 in value.
Prep & Shipping Tips
- Place raw cards in penny sleeves & toploaders/semi-rigids.
- Team bag, then bubble wrap; use sturdy boxes with void fill.
- Include your name, email, phone, and order reference inside the box.
Commission & Payouts
We offer some of the highest consignor payouts in the industry. Our commission includes marketplace selling fees — no hidden extras.
| Sale Price Range | Columbia Commission | Your Payout |
|---|---|---|
| Under $10 | $3 | |
| $10 – $999.99 | 20% | 80% |
| $1000 – $4,999.99 | 18% | 82% |
| $5,000 + | 5% + $350 | 95% - $350 |
| $20,000.00 | Call or email | |
| Detailed sales report provided with every payout. | ||
Why Choose Columbia?
- Proven Reputation: 460,000+ eBay feedback, decades in the hobby.
- Reach: One of the largest buyer networks in cards & collectibles.
- Speed: Fast listing & responsive customer service.
- PSA Solutions: Official PSA Submission Center for grading + consignment.
- Secure Storage: Bonded warehouse & careful handling.
- Flexible Payouts: ACH, check, or store credit (with bonus).
FAQs
What if my item doesn’t sell?
We’ll re-list it or return it to you upon request. Return shipping may apply for bulk returns.
Can I set a reserve or minimum price?
No. All items are listed with a minimum 7 day auction (10 at our discretion) and a starting bid of $2.99. By submitting to us you agree that to let the auction run. We will not pull down active auctions.
Do you accept international consignors?
Yes. Shipping costs and payout timelines can vary by country.
Can you grade my cards before consigning?
Yes. As a PSA Submission Center, we can handle grading and then list your slabs upon return.
How are fees handled?
Our commission includes marketplace selling fees. Any optional services (e.g., grading, expedited imaging) are discussed and approved before we proceed.
Ready to Consign?
Start your submission in minutes — we’ll handle the rest.
Prefer grading first? Use our PSA submission form.
